This MySQL error occurs when attempting to create or alter a table with all columns marked as INVISIBLE. MySQL requires every table to have at least one visible column to ensure data can be retrieved via standard SELECT * queries.
The ER_TABLE_MUST_HAVE_VISIBLE_COLUMN (4028) error was introduced in MySQL 8.0.23 alongside the invisible columns feature. Invisible columns are hidden from SELECT * queries but can still be accessed when explicitly named. This provides a way to add columns without breaking existing application code that uses SELECT * statements. However, MySQL enforces a critical constraint: every table must have at least one visible column. This ensures that: 1. **Data Accessibility**: Standard SELECT * queries will always return at least one column, preventing empty result sets that could break applications. 2. **Table Structure Integrity**: A table with all invisible columns would be effectively unusable for most common database operations. 3. **Backward Compatibility**: Applications relying on SELECT * would fail if a table had no visible columns to return. The error occurs in two scenarios: when creating a new table with all columns marked INVISIBLE, or when altering an existing table to make all remaining visible columns invisible. This safeguard prevents accidental data hiding and ensures tables remain functional for standard SQL operations.
When creating a new table, omit the INVISIBLE keyword from at least one column:
-- This will FAIL with ER_TABLE_MUST_HAVE_VISIBLE_COLUMN:
CREATE TABLE users (
id INT PRIMARY KEY INVISIBLE,
email VARCHAR(255) INVISIBLE,
created_at TIMESTAMP INVISIBLE
);
-- This will SUCCEED - id is visible:
CREATE TABLE users (
id INT PRIMARY KEY,
email VARCHAR(255) INVISIBLE,
created_at TIMESTAMP INVISIBLE
);The visible column can be any column type - it doesn't have to be the primary key.
Before making columns invisible, verify the table has other visible columns:
-- Check which columns are currently visible
SELECT
COLUMN_NAME,
EXTRA
FROM
INFORMATION_SCHEMA.COLUMNS
WHERE
TABLE_SCHEMA = 'your_database'
AND TABLE_NAME = 'your_table'
AND EXTRA NOT LIKE '%INVISIBLE%';
-- Example result showing visible columns:
-- +-------------+-------+
-- | COLUMN_NAME | EXTRA |
-- +-------------+-------+
-- | id | |
-- | username | |
-- +-------------+-------+
-- Safe to make username invisible since id will remain visible:
ALTER TABLE your_table
ALTER COLUMN username SET INVISIBLE;
-- This would FAIL if id is the only visible column:
ALTER TABLE your_table
ALTER COLUMN id SET INVISIBLE;Always ensure at least one column remains visible after ALTER operations.
Explicitly mark required columns as VISIBLE to prevent accidental invisibility:
-- Explicitly set visibility for clarity
CREATE TABLE products (
product_id INT PRIMARY KEY VISIBLE,
product_name VARCHAR(255) VISIBLE,
internal_notes TEXT INVISIBLE,
debug_data JSON INVISIBLE,
legacy_field VARCHAR(100) INVISIBLE
);
-- When altering columns, use SET VISIBLE to ensure visibility:
ALTER TABLE products
ALTER COLUMN product_id SET VISIBLE;
-- Multiple columns can be modified in one statement:
ALTER TABLE products
MODIFY COLUMN product_name VARCHAR(255) VISIBLE,
MODIFY COLUMN internal_notes TEXT INVISIBLE;Explicit visibility declarations make schema intentions clear and prevent errors.
Update database migration scripts that create tables with invisible columns:
-- BAD: Migration will fail
CREATE TABLE IF NOT EXISTS audit_log (
log_id BIGINT AUTO_INCREMENT PRIMARY KEY INVISIBLE,
user_id INT INVISIBLE,
action VARCHAR(50) INVISIBLE,
timestamp DATETIME INVISIBLE
);
-- GOOD: At least one column is visible
CREATE TABLE IF NOT EXISTS audit_log (
log_id BIGINT AUTO_INCREMENT PRIMARY KEY, -- Visible
user_id INT INVISIBLE,
action VARCHAR(50) INVISIBLE,
timestamp DATETIME INVISIBLE
);
-- Or make multiple columns visible for better data access:
CREATE TABLE IF NOT EXISTS audit_log (
log_id BIGINT AUTO_INCREMENT PRIMARY KEY,
user_id INT,
action VARCHAR(50),
timestamp DATETIME,
debug_info JSON INVISIBLE, -- Only debug fields invisible
internal_flags VARCHAR(100) INVISIBLE
);Test migration scripts against MySQL 8.0.23+ before deployment.
If you encounter this error on existing tables, make one or more columns visible:
-- Check the current table structure
DESC your_table;
-- Or get detailed visibility information:
SHOW CREATE TABLE your_table;
-- Make a column visible using ALTER COLUMN:
ALTER TABLE your_table
ALTER COLUMN column_name SET VISIBLE;
-- Alternative syntax using MODIFY COLUMN:
ALTER TABLE your_table
MODIFY COLUMN column_name VARCHAR(255) VISIBLE;
-- Or using CHANGE COLUMN (allows renaming):
ALTER TABLE your_table
CHANGE COLUMN old_name new_name INT VISIBLE;
-- Verify the change:
SELECT COLUMN_NAME, EXTRA
FROM INFORMATION_SCHEMA.COLUMNS
WHERE TABLE_NAME = 'your_table'
ORDER BY ORDINAL_POSITION;Any column can be made visible - choose the one most useful for application queries.
The invisible columns feature was introduced in MySQL 8.0.23 as a solution for backward compatibility during schema evolution. Key advanced considerations:
1. Use Cases for Invisible Columns: Common scenarios include adding audit columns (created_at, updated_at), metadata fields, or debugging information that shouldn't appear in legacy SELECT * queries. This allows schema evolution without breaking existing application code.
2. Primary Key Visibility: While primary keys can be marked invisible, it's generally a bad practice. Invisible primary keys complicate data access and debugging. If you need auto-generated keys that don't appear in SELECT *, consider using Generated Invisible Primary Keys (GIPK) with sql_generate_invisible_primary_key=ON in MySQL 8.0.30+.
3. Index Behavior: Invisible columns can be included in indexes (including PRIMARY KEY and UNIQUE indexes). The invisibility only affects SELECT * queries, not index functionality or performance.
4. INSERT and UPDATE Operations: Invisible columns must be explicitly named in INSERT statements. They don't participate in INSERT statements without column lists, which can prevent accidental data omission.
5. Application Layer Considerations: ORMs and database frameworks that rely on SELECT * for automatic column mapping may not detect invisible columns. Ensure your ORM supports explicit column selection if using invisible columns.
6. Migration Strategy: When migrating from older MySQL versions, all columns are visible by default. The invisible columns feature is opt-in. Plan migrations carefully to avoid accidentally making all columns invisible during bulk schema changes.
7. Security Implications: Don't rely on invisible columns for security. They're a convenience feature, not a security mechanism. Users with appropriate privileges can still SELECT invisible columns by name.
8. Performance: Invisible columns have no performance impact - they're stored and indexed identically to visible columns. The only difference is query behavior with SELECT *.
EE_WRITE (3): Error writing file
How to fix "EE_WRITE (3): Error writing file" in MySQL
CR_PARAMS_NOT_BOUND (2031): No data supplied for parameters
How to fix "CR_PARAMS_NOT_BOUND (2031): No data supplied for parameters" in MySQL
CR_DNS_SRV_LOOKUP_FAILED (2070): DNS SRV lookup failed
How to fix "CR_DNS_SRV_LOOKUP_FAILED (2070): DNS SRV lookup failed" in MySQL
ERROR 1146: Table 'database.table' doesn't exist
How to fix "ERROR 1146: Table doesn't exist" in MySQL
ERROR 1040: Too many connections
How to fix "ERROR 1040: Too many connections" in MySQL